Normal Glucose and A1C, But Still Overweight and Exhausted? It Could Be Insulin Resistance

If your blood sugar and A1C look normal, but you’re exhausted, gaining weight, and struggling with brain fog, you may have insulin resistance and not even know it.

This is a common pattern I see in practice. Many people are told their lab work is “normal,” yet they’re dealing with fatigue, memory problems, weight gain, digestive issues, and chronic inflammation. Often, the missing piece is that insulin levels aren’t being checked.

One of my favorite patient success stories involves a 55-year-old woman whose blood sugar appeared normal, yet deeper testing revealed the underlying cause of her symptoms.

A 55-Year-Old Woman Struggling with Multiple Symptoms

This patient came to my clinic experiencing a wide range of symptoms, including:

  • Fatigue
  • Poor memory and concentration
  • Indigestion
  • Gas and bloating
  • Constipation
  • Dry, itchy skin
  • Neck, back, and joint pain
  • Insomnia
  • Depression
  • Weight gain

She was frustrated because despite trying to improve her health, she continued to gain weight and felt worse over time.

The Surprising Lab Results

I ordered comprehensive laboratory testing, which revealed something many people overlook.

While her:

  • Glucose was normal
  • A1C was normal

She also had:

  • Elevated fasting insulin
  • Elevated ferritin

Together, these findings indicated insulin resistance.

Many people associate high ferritin with iron overload, but one of the most common reasons I see elevated ferritin is insulin resistance and chronic inflammation.

This finding helped explain many of her symptoms and provided an important clue about what was happening beneath the surface.

Looking Deeper for the Root Causes

Rather than stopping with the insulin resistance diagnosis, I performed additional functional testing to determine why her body was inflamed and struggling in the first place.

The testing revealed:

  • Positive celiac genetics
  • Gluten sensitivity
  • Leaky gut
  • Food sensitivities, including dairy
  • Candida yeast overgrowth
  • Low omega-3 fatty acids
  • Elevated omega-6 fatty acids
  • Low cortisol levels
  • Multiple nutritional imbalances

These findings showed that insulin resistance was only one piece of a much larger picture.

The Connection Between Gut Health and Insulin Resistance

Many patients are surprised to learn how closely gut health and insulin resistance are connected.

Here’s how these factors often interact:

Leaky Gut and Chronic Inflammation

When the intestinal barrier becomes compromised, inflammation can spread throughout the body.

This ongoing inflammatory burden can interfere with normal insulin function and contribute to metabolic dysfunction.

Inflammation Drives Insulin Resistance

Chronic inflammation makes it harder for cells to respond appropriately to insulin.

As insulin resistance develops, the body often produces more insulin to compensate, creating a cycle that can lead to fatigue, weight gain, and other symptoms.

Insulin Resistance Can Elevate Ferritin

Ferritin is often viewed strictly as an iron marker, but it can also rise as part of the body’s inflammatory response.

In this patient’s case, the elevated ferritin reflected underlying inflammation and metabolic dysfunction rather than simply excess iron.

The Three-Step Plan That Helped Her Recover

To address her health concerns, we focused on three key areas:

  1. Comprehensive testing
  2. An anti-inflammatory diet
  3. Targeted nutritional support

Step 1: Comprehensive Testing

Many routine evaluations fail to identify insulin resistance because insulin is often not included in standard blood work.

Typical testing may include:

  • CBC (Complete Blood Count)
  • Comprehensive Metabolic Panel
  • Lipid Panel
  • TSH

However, I also recommend evaluating:

  • Fasting insulin
  • Hemoglobin A1C
  • Uric acid
  • Ferritin
  • Serum iron
  • TIBC
  • Iron saturation
  • CRP
  • LDH
  • GGT
  • Free T3
  • Free T4

These markers can provide additional insight into inflammation, metabolic health, thyroid function, and nutrient status.

In her case, checking insulin and ferritin revealed insulin resistance that would have otherwise been missed.

Additional functional testing helped uncover nutrient deficiencies, food sensitivities, infections, hormonal imbalances, and other root causes contributing to her symptoms.

Step 2: Following the FreeDiet®

The cornerstone of her plan was the FreeDiet®, an anti-inflammatory nutrition program I developed while overcoming my own health challenges, including:

  • Hashimoto’s thyroiditis
  • Rheumatoid arthritis
  • IBS
  • Fatigue
  • Skin and other health issues

The FreeDiet® removes foods commonly associated with inflammation and digestive dysfunction, including:

  • Gluten
  • Grains
  • Sugar
  • Yeast
  • Dairy
  • Eggs
  • Soy
  • Legumes
  • Nightshades
  • Processed foods

By removing these common triggers, many patients experience improvements in gut health, energy, inflammation, and metabolic function.

What Does the FreeDiet® Look Like?

Breakfast

A nutrient-dense FreeDiet® Super Smoothie that includes:

  • High-quality protein
  • Essential fats
  • Fruits
  • Vegetables
  • Fiber

Lunch and Dinner

Meals focused on:

  • Beef
  • Chicken
  • Fish
  • Plenty of vegetables
  • Healthy fats

Tips for Insulin Resistance

For patients with insulin resistance, I also recommend:

  • Avoiding frequent snacking
  • Maintaining approximately a 12-hour overnight fast between dinner and breakfast
  • Eliminating processed foods and inflammatory seed oils

In my experience, this strategy often provides excellent results without the need for prolonged intermittent fasting.

Step 3: Targeted Supplements

Based on her testing results, she was placed on a personalized supplement protocol.

This included the Functional Five™:

  • Multivitamin
  • Fish oil
  • Vitamin D with K
  • Magnesium
  • Probiotic

Additional support included:

As always, supplement recommendations were based on her individual test results. Not every patient requires the same program.

Results After Just Seven Weeks

Her progress was remarkable.

After only seven weeks:

  • Her digestion improved significantly
  • Energy levels increased
  • Memory and concentration improved
  • Joint and body pain decreased
  • She lost 10 pounds

Even more importantly, her laboratory markers improved dramatically:

  • Insulin resistance score HOMA-IR decreased by 57%, from 2.88 to 1.3
  • HIGH ferritin dropped from 152 to 98, reaching an optimal range for her situation

For the first time in years, she was seeing measurable improvements in both her symptoms and underlying health markers.

Four Months Later

By her four-month follow-up, she continued to improve.

She reported:

  • No fatigue
  • No memory problems
  • No indigestion
  • No joint pain
  • No insomnia
  • No depression

Her insulin and ferritin levels were both in optimal ranges.

She had also lost a total of 14 pounds and was thrilled with her progress.

The Takeaway

Insulin resistance can exist even when glucose and A1C appear completely normal.

That’s why it’s important to look beyond standard lab work when symptoms such as fatigue, brain fog, weight gain, digestive issues, and inflammation persist.

In this patient’s case, the real problem wasn’t simply elevated ferritin or weight gain. It was a combination of:

  • Insulin resistance
  • Leaky gut
  • Gluten sensitivity
  • Candida overgrowth
  • Nutrient deficiencies
  • Chronic inflammation
  • Adrenal dysfunction

By identifying and addressing these root causes, she was able to restore her energy, improve her gut health, normalize her insulin and ferritin levels, lose weight, and regain her quality of life.

Looking for Answers to Fatigue, Brain Fog, or Weight Gain?

If you’re dealing with fatigue, brain fog, weight gain, digestive symptoms, or other chronic health concerns, proper testing may help uncover hidden issues such as insulin resistance, nutrient deficiencies, gut dysfunction, or chronic inflammation.

You shouldn’t have to live with symptoms without understanding what’s causing them.

If you’d like personalized guidance, contact the Natural Medicine Clinic to learn more about identifying and addressing the root causes of your health concerns.

Go here if you would like a free copy of the FreeDiet® phase 1 food chart.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • freediet-img

    Download The FreeDiet® Phase 1 Food Chart

    from Dr. Rofrano's best-selling book, The FreeDiet®

    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

    Success Stories

    Natural treatment for Migraine Headaches, neck pain, digestive problems, fatigue.
    To read more and to view full-sized video, click HERE

    Rebecca Dyckman profile picture
    Rebecca Dyckman
    5 years ago
    I began treatment under Dr. Tom and Dawn in early August. I had a shopping list of complaints. Many of them I'd been dealing with for 25 to 30 years. Traditional doctors told me again and again that I was perfectly healthy, implying that much of this was in my head. Dr. Tom ran numerous tests based on his hunches, and I'm glad that he did. Tests revealed many things never uncovered by any of my previous doctors. I began feeling relief from some symptoms within a few days and gradually began feeling relief from most others. I'm about 5 weeks into the program and feeling so much better. I had concerns about sticking it out because it is definitely a vastly different way of doing things and it is quite an investment. But there is a light at the end of the tunnel. This is the first time in my many years of trying to get better that I can actually see that light. I am excited to update in another few months because I feel certain that I'll be able to report that I am fully healed. Thank you Dr. Tom and Dawn (and Angelika). You all are an amazing team and I feel blessed that you all are working so hard to get me well. Thank you!!
    Andrea Fiebe profile picture
    Andrea Fiebe
    5 years ago
    I am beyond grateful for Dr. Tom and his staff!! Kayla, Dawn and Alexandra have gone out of their way to help me and I know my situation hasn't been easy. I came to Dr. Tom with a long list of issues and hopeless. I am proud to say that a year later and I am thriving. I went from not working out at all to working out 4 days a week, plus yoga. I traveled around the country to many holistic doctors and he has been the only way to help me see major progress. My only regret is that I didn't meet him sooner. I feel taken care of and so grateful for my experience with them.
    Amanda Bailey profile picture
    Amanda Bailey
    5 years ago
    Dr. Tom Rofrano's Natural Medicine Clinic has changed my life. I came to him with an enlarged thyroid nodule, pain in my joints and tendons, increasing weight, imbalanced hormones, a leaky gut and so many other issues that I didn't even know were causing my symptoms. After extensive testing, he put me on a tailored protocol as well as the Free Diet (trademarked) to help clear up my symptoms. I have been on this protocol for 5 months and I have never felt better. I have more energy, reduced stress, overall happiness, no pain in my joints, clear skin, better menstrual cycles, no pms symptoms of irritability or mood swings. I lost 20 lbs and my gut is healing. All with supplements, dietary changes, and environmental changes to my daily life. I emphatically endorse this method and hope everyone seeks him out. He got to the root cause of my symptoms and I am on a path to heal myself holistically without traditional medicine. In addition to Dr. Rofrano, everyone in his clinic is extremely helpful and generous with their time. I have never met a more caring team of support from a clinic. Thank you to Kayla and Angelika and all the NMC support team for what they have done for me. In addition, I don't even live nearby and Dr. Rofrano and his team have worked to ship all my tests and supplies to me, Zoom my follow up visits, and help me find what I need in my area. So grateful to them all. -Amanda Bailey
    Christine VanBasten profile picture
    Christine VanBasten
    5 years ago
    I was diagnosed with ulcerative colitis in 2001 and have had severe abdominal swelling since 2008. People continuously asked me when my baby was due and I was never pregnant. I didn't want to be in public or go to work because I didn't feel well and I was extremely self conscious of my body shape. Since starting the FreeDiet in March 2021, I have lost 12 pounds. I am no longer bloated and all my coltis symptoms have disappeared. After completing extensive bloodwork and testing Dr. Rofrano discovered that I am allergic to Gluten and Candida. I knew I was allergic to Gluten and knew that I struggled with Candida but never realized I could be allergic to Candida as well. After eliminating anything fermented from my diet, I feel pain free in my stomach. Food is enjoyable once again. I am very happy with my improved health and energy thanks to this diet, supplements and to Dr. Rofrano. My colleagues are commenting and how healthy and young I look. I highly recommend Dr. Rofrano and all his services.
    Troy Stark profile picture
    Troy Stark
    5 years ago
    Testosterone gain of 50% in 30 days with NO drugs. DR. Tom’s nutrition and supplement guidance is foolproof, however, it’s up to you to do the work. My bloodwork improved amazingly across the full spectrum. If you want to be healthy and actually see the lab results go to NMC!
    Betty Diller profile picture
    Betty Diller
    6 years ago
    I was in a very sickly state with very high blood pressure, Epstein Barr Virus, severe digestive issues, IBS, and constant UTI ‘s that were always back to back. My cholesterol was 244 and my inflammation was off the charts / extremely high!!!! I decided to read “free diet” book written by Dr Rofrano. It made total sense, so I decided to proceed with the blood tests. This is when I discovered all my lab work was in a very poor state. He uncovered a lot of information and made me aware of why my health was poor and why I was feeling badly!!! I started to follow the diet and take the suggested supplements. Within 5 to 6 weeks everything turned around for me. My labs were nearly perfect in all the previously scary areas where the numbers were completely out of range. I am feeling much better and I am raving about the free diet / supplements that Dr Rofrano can offer you for your specific issues. he is gifted to know exactly how to help each person deal with their health issues. I am grateful to God I found him and had the initiative to move forward!!!! PTL !!!!
    Janet Oquendo profile picture
    Janet Oquendo
    6 years ago
    My health had been declining over the last 5 years. I have consulted with no less than 6 naturopaths. Non of which was able to help me regain my health. After more recent lab tests my Feritin level had skyrocketed at which point now I was worried. Every one I spoke to said the only option was to do leeching (where they draw out your blood periodically). That did not sound like an option. Then I found Dr Rofrano. To be honest I was extremely skeptical as I have spend lots of money and time with other naturopaths only to end up right back at the beginning. However I had nothing to loose (other than $$$) I decided to give him one try before I competely gave up. I can say I am 100% happy!!!... After an in-depth consultation, and extensive testing. Many deficiencies were uncovered not to mention, sensitivities, thyroid, hormones, high cholesterol the list goes on and on. We began a supplement regiment to get things back on track. Its now 6 weeks later. My labs have significantly improved, my cholesterol is now in normal range, my feritin level has significantly dropped and I am feeling a lot better. Its still early and my body has more healing to do. I am ecstatic to say we are on the right track. My labs have never looked better. If you are just not feeling well and really need to find a solution would highly recommend you contact the Natural Medicine Clinic and speak to Dr Tom Rofrano.. you will NOT be dissapointed.
    Shannon Empfield profile picture
    Shannon Empfield
    6 years ago
    Great Dr. his book is amazing and the supplements they sell are of highest quality. I’ve been taking them for years now and my health has improved greatly. I highly recommend Natural Medicine Clinic.
    D M profile picture
    D M
    6 years ago
    Stay away. Extremely expensive for results. All they want to do is throw pills at you for thousands of dollars.. Not worth the money. Find someone who takes an interest in your health not your wallet.
    Eric Myskowski profile picture
    Eric Myskowski
    6 years ago
    If you’re looking to take back your health and move foreword into longevity, I highly suggest Dr. Rofrano and his excellent team. They provide you with step by step guidance on how to make all your health dreams a reality. Be ready to commit to his individualized program for the best results possible. I would recommend Dr. Rofrano and his practice to anyone and everyone looking to finally understand your health and what it takes to get back to living the life you want to live. This is what real health is all about.
    More reviews

    Hours

    Monday 9 AM – 5 PM
    Tuesday 9 AM – 5 PM
    Wednesday 9 AM – 5 PM
    Thursday 9 AM – 5 PM
    Friday 9 AM – 1 PM

  • Schedule An
    Appointment

    We can help you look and feel the best you have in years!

    Natural Medicine Clinic

    Chiropractor Palm Beach Gardens, FL
    2401 PGA Boulevard Ste 132
    Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
    561-627-5800

    Serving the Florida communities of:

    Palm Beach Gardens, North Palm Beach,
    Jupiter, Tequesta, Singer Island
    and West Palm Beach.

    Content on this website is based upon the opinions of Thomas Rofrano, D.C. and is not considered medical advice. It is designed to be a sharing of knowledge and information from the research and experience of Dr. Rofrano and his community. Dr. Rofrano encourages you to make your health care decisions based upon your research and in partnership with a qualified health care professional. Dr. Rofrano is a chiropractic physician and offers physical and nutritional support and guidance to those seeking alternative or complementary care to traditional medicine. His care is not meant to replace that from your primary doctor and specialists but rather to help you on your path to achieving life-long vibrant health.

    Regarding any supplements mentioned: *These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your physician before using this product.